Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2011 House Bill 5085: Ban government sending payroll PAC money to union (Senate Roll Call 73)
facebook  twitter 

Passed 26 to 12 in the Senate on February 14, 2012, to prohibit the state, school districts and local governments from deducting money from an employee’s paycheck and contributing it to a union Political Action Committee (PAC).
View All of House Bill 5085: History, Amendments & Comments 

The vote was 26 in favor, 12 against, and 0 not voting.
(Senate Roll Call 73)

Print-friendly version

 Comment on this vote   View others' comments   Add to scorecard 

Line

Vote
In Favor In Favor
Against Against
Not Voting Not Voting
 Undecided
Democrat
1000%
100100%
1000%
12 total votes
Republican
100100%
1000%
1000%
26 total votes
Voters
1000%
100100%
1000%
2 total votes

What do you think? In Favor Against Undecided (log on required)

Line

Ban government sending payroll PAC money to union

IN FAVOR

SENATE DEMOCRATS
none

SENATE REPUBLICANS

Booher (R)Brandenburg (R)Casperson (R)Caswell (R)Colbeck (R)
Emmons (R)Green (R)Hansen (R)Hildenbrand (R)Hune (R)
Jansen (R)Jones (R)Kahn (R)Kowall (R)Marleau (R)
Meekhof (R)Moolenaar (R)Nofs (R)Pappageorge (R)Pavlov (R)
Proos (R)Richardville (R)Robertson (R)Rocca (R)Schuitmaker (R)
Walker (R)    


AGAINST

SENATE DEMOCRATS

Anderson (D)Bieda (D)Gleason (D)Gregory (D)Hood (D)
Hopgood (D)Hunter (D)Johnson (D)Smith (D)Warren (D)
Whitmer (D)Young (D)   

SENATE REPUBLICANS
none




SENATE LEGISLATORS ALL VOTES

  n  Anderson (D)  n  Bieda (D)Y    Booher (R)Y    Brandenburg (R)Y    Casperson (R)
Y    Caswell (R)Y    Colbeck (R)Y    Emmons (R)  n  Gleason (D)Y    Green (R)
  n  Gregory (D)Y    Hansen (R)Y    Hildenbrand (R)  n  Hood (D)  n  Hopgood (D)
Y    Hune (R)  n  Hunter (D)Y    Jansen (R)  n  Johnson (D)Y    Jones (R)
Y    Kahn (R)Y    Kowall (R)Y    Marleau (R)Y    Meekhof (R)Y    Moolenaar (R)
Y    Nofs (R)Y    Pappageorge (R)Y    Pavlov (R)Y    Proos (R)Y    Richardville (R)
Y    Robertson (R)Y    Rocca (R)Y    Schuitmaker (R)  n  Smith (D)Y    Walker (R)
  n  Warren (D)  n  Whitmer (D)  n  Young (D)  

Senate Roll Call 73 on 2011 House Bill 5085

Line

Comments

Re: 2011 House Bill 5085 (Ban government sending payroll PAC money to union)  by jgurma on May 9, 2012 

Creator noesis eff for me,Unoriginality companionate that you are one of the personalized bloggers I e'er saw.Thanks for fit this informatory cut
here


Re: 2011 House Bill 5085 (Ban government sending payroll PAC money to union)  by harrynevus on February 8, 2012 

 Why should state and local governments allow deductions for union PACs?   Because this is one of the things payroll departments do in this country.  They set up automatic deductons for credit union/bank deposits, loan payments, United Way contributons,  wage garnishments, child support, IRS levies, union initiation fees, union dues, PACs, and so on and so on.  But these legislators don't care about these deductions.  These don't bother them at all.


So, let's call it what it is.  This is a republican controlled legislature sending bills to a republican governor and this involves unionized employees that decided to have a deduction of a dollar amount of their choosing, sent to a Political Action Committee.  Since members of unions are traditionally Democratic supporters, this republican legislature is saying, "Yep, THIS is where we draw the line.  "WE" will not condone or participate in any fundraising for the Democrats."


So, you're right.  Maybe we shouldn't have payroll staff enter ANY of these personal- choice deductions for ANY public employee.  They can all write checks to the United Fund, drop their deposit off at the bank, send a check to FotC, etc. 


But when the legislature selects one specific deduction to prohibit, it's discriminatory.  Automatic payroll deductions aren't illegal, and contributions to PACS aren't illegal, but payroll deductions of union PAC contributions are (or soon will be) illegal.  It's also discriminatory because it only addresses employees contributing to UNION political action committees.  It says nothing of employees that want to have money deducted for a republican based PAC.  No, this only addresses UNION PACs. 


It's not only discriminatory, but it's a clear example of elected officials using their power and position to benefit themselves with no thought or concern for the citizens' needs or desires.   I'd love to see what the AG says about this piece-of-crap legislation, or better yet, watch the Supreme Court try to squirm around it.



Re: 2011 House Bill 5085 (Ban government sending payroll PAC money to union)  by chrisv on November 2, 2011 

I agree that we should Ban government sending payroll PAC money to unions as the unions should never be part of the political process in the first place.



View More pre-2013 Comments.
Your new comments should be made in the box below.