Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2012 Senate Bill 1293: Repeal BCBS tax exemption; regulate like regular health insurer (House Roll Call 689)
facebook  twitter 

Passed 61 to 49 in the House on December 6, 2012, to convert Blue Cross Blue Shield into a “nonprofit mutual insurance company” (technically "owned" by the policy holders), make it subject to the same regulations as regular health insurers, and no longer exempt BCBS from state and local taxes.
View All of Senate Bill 1293: History, Amendments & Comments 

The vote was 61 in favor, 49 against, and 0 not voting.
(House Roll Call 689)

Print-friendly version

 Comment on this vote   View others' comments   Add to scorecard 

Line

Vote
In Favor In Favor
Against Against
Not Voting Not Voting
 Undecided
Republican
95595%
4964%
1000%
64 total votes
Democrat
1000%
100100%
1000%
46 total votes

What do you think? In Favor Against Undecided (log on required)

Line

Repeal BCBS tax exemption; regulate like regular health insurer

IN FAVOR

HOUSE DEMOCRATS
none

HOUSE REPUBLICANS

Agema (R)Bolger (R)Bumstead (R)Callton (R)Cotter (R)
Crawford (R)Daley (R)Damrow (R)Denby (R)Farrington (R)
Forlini (R)Foster (R)Franz (R)Genetski (R)Gilbert (R)
Glardon (R)Goike (R)Graves (R)Haines (R)Haveman (R)
Heise (R)Hooker (R)Horn (R)Hughes (R)Huuki (R)
Jacobsen (R)Jenkins (R)Knollenberg (R)Kowall (R)Kurtz (R)
LaFontaine (R)Lori (R)Lund (R)Lyons (R)MacGregor (R)
MacMaster (R)McBroom (R)Muxlow (R)Nesbitt (R)O'Brien (R)
Olson (R)Opsommer (R)Ouimet (R)Outman (R)Pettalia (R)
Poleski (R)Potvin (R)Price (R)Pscholka (R)Rendon (R)
Rogers (R)Schmidt, R. (R)Schmidt, W. (R)Shaughnessy (R)Shirkey (R)
Somerville (R)Stamas (R)Tyler (R)Walsh (R)Yonker (R)
Zorn (R)    


AGAINST

HOUSE DEMOCRATS

Ananich (D)Barnett (D)Bauer (D)Bledsoe (D)Brown (D)
Brunner (D)Byrum (D)Cavanagh (D)Clemente (D)Constan (D)
Darany (D)Dillon (D)Durhal (D)Geiss (D)Greimel (D)
Hammel (D)Haugh (D)Hobbs (D)Hovey-Wright (D)Howze (D)
Irwin (D)Jackson (D)Kandrevas (D)Lane (D)LeBlanc (D)
Lindberg (D)Lipton (D)Liss (D)McCann (D)Meadows (D)
Nathan (D)Oakes (D)Olumba (D)Rutledge (D)Santana (D)
Segal (D)Slavens (D)Smiley (D)Stallworth (D)Stanley (D)
Stapleton (D)Switalski (D)Talabi (D)Tlaib (D)Townsend (D)
Womack (D)    

HOUSE REPUBLICANS

Johnson (R)McMillin (R)Moss (R)




HOUSE LEGISLATORS ALL VOTES

Y    Agema (R)  n  Ananich (D)  n  Barnett (D)  n  Bauer (D)  n  Bledsoe (D)
Y    Bolger (R)  n  Brown (D)  n  Brunner (D)Y    Bumstead (R)  n  Byrum (D)
Y    Callton (R)  n  Cavanagh (D)  n  Clemente (D)  n  Constan (D)Y    Cotter (R)
Y    Crawford (R)Y    Daley (R)Y    Damrow (R)  n  Darany (D)Y    Denby (R)
  n  Dillon (D)  n  Durhal (D)Y    Farrington (R)Y    Forlini (R)Y    Foster (R)
Y    Franz (R)  n  Geiss (D)Y    Genetski (R)Y    Gilbert (R)Y    Glardon (R)
Y    Goike (R)Y    Graves (R)  n  Greimel (D)Y    Haines (R)  n  Hammel (D)
  n  Haugh (D)Y    Haveman (R)Y    Heise (R)  n  Hobbs (D)Y    Hooker (R)
Y    Horn (R)  n  Hovey-Wright (D)  n  Howze (D)Y    Hughes (R)Y    Huuki (R)
  n  Irwin (D)  n  Jackson (D)Y    Jacobsen (R)Y    Jenkins (R)  n  Johnson (R)
  n  Kandrevas (D)Y    Knollenberg (R)Y    Kowall (R)Y    Kurtz (R)Y    LaFontaine (R)
  n  Lane (D)  n  LeBlanc (D)  n  Lindberg (D)  n  Lipton (D)  n  Liss (D)
Y    Lori (R)Y    Lund (R)Y    Lyons (R)Y    MacGregor (R)Y    MacMaster (R)
Y    McBroom (R)  n  McCann (D)  n  McMillin (R)  n  Meadows (D)  n  Moss (R)
Y    Muxlow (R)  n  Nathan (D)Y    Nesbitt (R)Y    O'Brien (R)  n  Oakes (D)
Y    Olson (R)  n  Olumba (D)Y    Opsommer (R)Y    Ouimet (R)Y    Outman (R)
Y    Pettalia (R)Y    Poleski (R)Y    Potvin (R)Y    Price (R)Y    Pscholka (R)
Y    Rendon (R)Y    Rogers (R)  n  Rutledge (D)  n  Santana (D)Y    Schmidt, R. (R)
Y    Schmidt, W. (R)  n  Segal (D)Y    Shaughnessy (R)Y    Shirkey (R)  n  Slavens (D)
  n  Smiley (D)Y    Somerville (R)  n  Stallworth (D)Y    Stamas (R)  n  Stanley (D)
  n  Stapleton (D)  n  Switalski (D)  n  Talabi (D)  n  Tlaib (D)  n  Townsend (D)
Y    Tyler (R)Y    Walsh (R)  n  Womack (D)Y    Yonker (R)Y    Zorn (R)

House Roll Call 689 on 2012 Senate Bill 1293

Line

Comments

Re: 2012 Senate Bill 1293 (Repeal BCBS tax exemption; regulate like regular health insurer)  by gregtt on November 21, 2012 
Well if the Blue Cross behaves like a commercial provider, it should be taxed all like commercial providers. But according to a report I read by John Studzinski, only two of the five companies provided examples of similar cases. Blue Cross-Blue Shield said it had had no opportunity to examine the cases and added that the commercial insurers were not identified.

Re: 2012 Senate Bill 1293 (Repeal BCBS tax exemption; regulate like regular health insurer)  by isabelleelise on November 13, 2012 

This is wealth confiscation for a Governor slush fund.  Communism.  Why doesn't the state just take the whole company right now?  You know that's the end game here.  Nothing will get better until the free market is restored across the board in the health care industry.  It's the only way.  We are so far from it now though... it's so horrible.  Where are the free market thinkers?  Not in Lansing.



2012 Senate Bill 1293 (Repeal BCBS tax exemption; regulate like regular health insurer)  by admin on November 13, 2012 
Introduced in the Senate on September 19, 2012, to convert Blue Cross Blue Shield into a “nonprofit mutual insurance company” (technically "owned" by the policy holders), make it subject to the same regulations as regular health insurers, and no longer exempt BCBS from state and local taxes. The bill requires BCBS to spend $1.5 billion in accumulated reserves over 18 years to augment government health welfare programs

The vote was 33 in favor, 4 opposed and 1 not voting

(Senate Roll Call 725 at Senate Journal 0)

Click here to view bill details.

View More pre-2013 Comments.
Your new comments should be made in the box below.